Open-pit vs. underground mining

The following is an excerpt from the ninth edition of Mining Explained, published by The Northern Miner. The book sells for $30 plus $3 for shipping and is available by calling 1-800-668-2374. E-mail: northernminer2@northernminer.com.

An open-pit mine is the least expensive kind, and is every developer’s first choice when an orebody is close to surface and big enough, and has little overburden.

Open-pit mines look simple, but every pit needs to be tailor-made. First and foremost, the pit walls have to stay up, so a rock-mechanics engineer has to determine a safe slope for the pit. There is also a delicate balance between how much waste rock can be mined in order to gain access to the valuable ore and how deep a pit can be.

The size and location of the first bench of any open-pit mine is critical. It is excavated well into the waste rock surrounding an orebody. And since each successive bench is smaller than the last one taken, the depth to which the pit can be mined is determined by the size and location of the first cut or bench.

The amount of waste rock mined relative to the amount of ore mined is called the stripping ratio. In most cases, this ratio is high for the first bench and decreases steadily with each successive bench. A stripping ratio of 3-to-1 means that during the life of the pit, there will be three times as much waste rock mined as ore. To be profitable, an open-pit mine must be designed so that the cost of mining the waste rock does not exceed the value of the ore.

The main cost advantage of open-pit mining is that the miners can use larger and more powerful shovels and trucks. The equipment is not restricted by the size of the opening it must work in. This allows faster production, and the lower cost also permits lower grades of ore to be mined.

If an orebody is large, and extends from surface to great depth, it is common to start mining near the surface from an open pit. This provides some early revenue while preparations are made for underground mining of the deeper parts of the orebody. In those circumstances, it is not uncommon for ore below the floor of an open pit to be developed from underground by driving a ramp from the lower part of the pit.

Underground methods

Generally, orebodies are either vein-type, massive or tabular in shape. This, together with ore thickness and regularity, will influence the mining method selected.

Vein-type orebodies usually dip steeply, allowing ore to fall to a lower mining level where it can be loaded. The orebodies are usually narrow and often irregular, so care must be taken to avoid mining barren wall rock. They are most successfully mined by small-scale underground stoping.

Massive orebodies are large and usually have an irregular shape. Underground bulk-mining methods, with large stopes, are best suited to this type of orebody.

Tabular orebodies are flat or gently dipping, and the ore, having nowhere to fall, must be handled where it is blasted. The thicknesses of the orebodies vary. Room-and-pillar mining is normally used to extract the ore. Depending on the thickness and lateral extent of the ore, these types of deposits tend to be moderate-to-high-tonnage producers.

The strength of the ore and the rocks surrounding an orebody also influence the method (and therefore the costs) used to mine the orebody. Openings may be supported or self-supported. Some supported openings are held up by backfill, waste rock or aggregate placed in the openings shortly after they are mined out. Others are held up by timber sets (supports made of timber or steel), though this kind of mining is costly and not generally used today.

Self-supported openings stand up with little artificial support. The walls and pillars are sufficiently strong to carry the weight of rock above them and the horizontal stresses in the rock caused by tectonic forces, though the miner may help them along with rock bolts and screening. In massive orebodies, it is common to plan for the mining of pillars. This is done by backfilling the mined-out stopes to provide the necessary support when the pillars are mined.

Print


 

Republish this article

Be the first to comment on "Open-pit vs. underground mining"

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*


By continuing to browse you agree to our use of cookies. To learn more, click more information

Dear user, please be aware that we use cookies to help users navigate our website content and to help us understand how we can improve the user experience. If you have ideas for how we can improve our services, we’d love to hear from you. Click here to email us. By continuing to browse you agree to our use of cookies. Please see our Privacy & Cookie Usage Policy to learn more.

Close